Using the BioBlitz Data in Class
A BioBlitz is a 24-hour biological inventory whose goal is to find as many species of organisms as possible. Our two main goals for the BioBlitz are educating students about the science of ecology in the city and cataloguing as many species as we can in 24 hours. Students will get a rich experience with real scientific data collection in a complex ecosystem.
The following are some ideas for using the students’ experiences and collected data from the BioBlitz in your Seminar 3 curriculum. We encourage you to have students present any BioBlitz- related analysis at the Seminar 3 Scientific Poster Session (the final common event).
All collected data will be freely available for use in class. This includes a list of the different species found during the BioBlitz and individual observations that are time-stamped and geotagged from the iNaturalist database. To get an idea of what will be available, you can explore previous year’s results from Central Park (2013), the New York Botanical Garden (2014), Freshkills Park (2015), and Brooklyn Bridge Park (2016) here: macaulay.cuny.edu/eportfolios/bioblitz/data/
Students can practice data visualization as well as some basic analysis. Students may also add information to the collected data that can be researched outside of the BioBlitz (invasion status, for example). In some cases, species diversity indices may be calculated; see references below for more information:
- Chao A, RL Chazdon, RK Colwell, and TJ Shen. 2005. A new statistical approach for assessing similarity of species composition with incidence and abundance data. Ecology Letters. 8:148-159. * The diversity analysis used in this paper was created by Colwell and is available here: viceroy.eeb.uconn.edu/EstimateS/
- Knapp S and R Wittig. 2012. An analysis of temporal homogenization and differentiation in Central European village floras. Basic and Applied Ecology. 13:319-327.
Students may want to collect more data after their BioBlitz experience. The host parks may allow classes to visit to collect more species diversity data, individual counts, or other measurements. Contact Dr. Kelly O’Donnell (email@example.com) for more information.
There are a number of good discussions to have regarding the type of data collected at the BioBlitz. Have students discuss the pros and cons of collecting data in this way. These data are a snapshot, what would be some different methods of data collection? Why would a scientist choose one over another? How are the question being asked and the data collection method related? Brainstorm what kinds of questions can be addressed with these data.
For a review of issues that come about when trying to quantify biodiversity, see:
- Gotelli NJ and RK Colwell. 2001. Quantifying biodiversity: procedures and pitfalls in the measurement and comparison of species richness. Ecology Letters. 4:379-391.
iNaturalist recently (June 2017) added an automatic ID suggesting feature to the app that attempts to identify the species you are looking at based on visual similarity, community intelligence, and location. This presents a great opportunity to discuss the advantages and limitations of machine learning. Here is a popular press article from The Atlantic about the iNaturalist update: Finally: An App That Can Identify the Animal You Saw on Your Hike
The BioBlitz can be useful as a part of a larger lesson about urban ecology. It can be used to address concepts such as:
- Island Biogeography (What are islands in the city? How might the immigration/extinction dynamics of the New York Botanical Garden differ from other urban parks?)
- Interspecies Interactions (Which species surveyed interact with each other? Create a trophic web of possible interactions.)
- Metapopulation Structure (What is a metapopulation? Are all individuals of the same species in the park one population? How would you test this?)
Science and Society Discussions
What is citizen science? What are some benefits and concerns when collecting data this way? Are these projects useful from a societal perspective? What might some benefits be to citizens of the city?
See the following paper for more info:
- Cohn, JP. 2008. Citizen science: can volunteers do real research? BioScience. 58(3):192-197.
Have students write a reflective essay on their experience at the BioBlitz. Do they feel more connected to nature in the city? Why/how? How has the BioBlitz changed the student’s view of how scientists do their work?