November 2, 2012, Friday, 306

User:DanielT

From The Peopling of New York City

DANIEL THENGONE

After reading Jill Lepore's New York Burning, I was fascinated by this less well-known topic of slavery in New York City. The objective of this project is to search for those immigrants,who have been a part of the history of New York City, but have not been prominent. My search for the five slave owners assigned to me led me to the geneology database www.ancestry.com. With this minimal information, I ventured to the New York Public Library, where I spent several hours glancing through books, journals, city directories and such census-related books. It was fascinating to go through these ancient documents and journals, some of which were in really bad condition. After searching for the "elusive immigrants" I was not able to find much. This scrutinizing process was very enlightening, although it did not bear me much fruit in regard to my project. But it did give me enough information to choose my next destination which is the Municipal Archives.


Contents

Research Project Proposal

Man-snowboarding-Mammoth-Mountain-CA--C11961282.jpeg

For my research, I would like to focus on the slave owners of New York City. Therefore I will be working on the slave conspiracy After reading New York Burning by Jill Lepore, I became interested in finding out more about these slave owners. The events that occurred between the slaves and these owners have led to the establishment of several political and social liberties that are present today. To further understand these issues, I feel that tracking the lives of these slave owners will be beneficial to the study of the slaves in New York City.

For my research I have been interested in the following people. Capt. Josiah Bagley, who was of French ethnicity owned a slave named Jemmy. Stephen Bayard was a Dutch merchant and a slave trader who owned slave named Ben. Mordecai Gomez, a Jew was a merchant who owned a slave named Cajoe (Africa). He was also a slave trader. Dr. James Henderson, an Englishman was a physician who owned a slave named Caesar. Ebener Pemberton, another Englishman was a minister, who owned a slave named Quamino. Cornelius Van Horne was a Dutch merchant who was involved in the slave trade and owned a slave named Kid. John Tiebout was a Dutch blockmaker, who owned a slave named Jack, and was also a slave trader. Capt. Jacob Sarly was a Dutch mariner, who owned a slave named Juan de la Silva. John Provost was a Dutch merchant who owned a slave, Lowe, and was also a slave trader. Capt. Robert Livingston Jr. was a English lawyer who owned a slave named Tom.

Slavery has been a major issue in the country that has led to the development of significant laws and court decisions. This topic has interested me because I have always wondered the plight of these slaves, and their owners. Although there is the tendency to view these owners as mere ruthless people, I wondered if all the slaves were treated alike. This research into the lives of slave owners will enable me to better comprehend the ambiguities and truths present in the slavery in New York City, and even the slave trade itself.

Slave Owners

Slave owner: Ethnicity; Wealth; Party affiliation; Occupation; Ward; Slave's name; Slave's final outcome

  1. John Chambers: English; 85 pounds wealth; Court Party; lawyer; West Ward; Cuba burned
  2. James DeBrousses: French; 25 pounds wealth; Country Party; distiller; Montgomerie Ward; Primus transported
  3. Mordecai Gomez: Jewish; 100 pounds wealth; merchant/slave trader; East Ward; Cajoe (alias Africa) transported & Jack accused but not found
  4. John Provost: Dutch; 20 pounds wealth; Country Party; cooper; North Ward; Cato (alias Toby) hanged
  5. Cornelius Van Horne: Dutch; 180 pounds wealth; Country Party; merchant/slave trader; East Ward; Kid discharged

Research

John Chambers

New York Weekly

My search for John chambers was a particularly tedious one. My exploration began in Lepore’s New York Burning which gave me information regarding his slaves. With very minimal information I began my journey by first searching online on www.ancestry.com and then extended my research through city directories at the New York Public Library. As I had expected I was bombarded with nearly hundreds of people named John Chambers. Although this was a major predicament, I was able to utilize the given information from Lepore’s book to my advantage. The main clue that enabled me to rule out the wrong choices was the profession, lawyer, which Lepore mentions in her book.[1] Although there were more than one John Chambers who was lived during the 1700s who were lawyers, I narrowed my results to one when I checked it to be one from the Court Party. From here I continued to use these information to further my research. After several hours of tediously searching through old ad dusty books, I came across a will that was written by John Chambers which mentioned his family members. Family members who were mentioned in the will were his wife Gennett; four sons, William, John, Henry and Thomas; and his daughters Anna Warren, Elisabeth Holt and Sarah Turner[2]. And this was the only amount of information that was amassed on the first trip to the New York Public Library.


The second trip was the most enlightening one. While going through Daniel Horsemanden’s journal, he recorded that John Chambers was one of the main lawyers who played an important role in the Horsemanden trials of 1741, which led to the severe sentences of several slaves. [3] Through my research I found that Horsemanden had personally picked the lawyers for this case, and it was essential to be informed of the previous court cases, where John Chambers might have displayed his abilities. To my interest and fascination I was able to find out the case that had gained Chambers much acclaim. This was the Peter Zenger trial of the publisher Peter Zenger vs. governor William Cosby of 1735. In this trial, John Chambers was appointed to defend Zenger before Alexander Hamilton was given this authority.[4]. During this trial, one of the most important ideals established by Chambers was a unprejudiced jury. Chambers successfully insisted that the jury be chosen from all eligible New York landowners. Chambers’ persistence for a impartial jury is an attribute expected in juries today as well. But gradually Chambers disappeared from the Zenger case due to Hamilton’s prominent arguments, acquitting Zenger of all libelous charges, thus establishing the freedom of press in the First Amendment. John Chambers continued to become the Justice of the Supreme Court and continued in that position from 1751 to 1763. To prolong his legacy, Chambers left behind his acclaimed library, which is a clear indication of his education and the significance he gave to it. “His practice papers have largely survived, and if they reveal a man of sometimes careless method, they show nonetheless an effective and well-trained lawyer.” My research resumed at the municipal Archives, where I was able to find the death certificate which dated the death of john Chambers in 1764. I was glad that I was able to unearthen the neglected life of an ordinary American who had played such a significant role in our country.


I was able to come across a will of probably a later descendant and she has also mentioned the names of the slaves that she owned. This is a clear indication that the family continued to own slaves even after the death of Jon Chambers. The fact that she mentioned them in her will also shows that the family ere kind slaveowners who took enough care of their slaves. "Page 77.--In the name of God, Amen. I, ANNE CHAMBERS, of New York, widow of John Chambers, late of New York, Esq., being in perfect health. "My Body I commit to the Earth to be buried in my Brother's family vault at the Lower Yonkers, in Westchester County." "I leave to the Rector and Inhabitants of the city of New York, in communion with the Church of England as by Law established, œ500 to be put at interest and the interest used for the support of the girls only, belonging to the Charity School, and for the rewarding such of the girls on their leaving School, as they judge deserving, which I intend as an incourgement of their Diligence." I leave to my nephew, Mr. Augustus Van Cortlandt, my negro wench and my negroes Dinah and Robins, and my chariot and horses..."[5].

James DeBrosses

James Debrosses was the most elusive immigrant of the bunch, meaning it was the hardest to find any information on. After searching through several directories at the New York Public Library and at the Municipal Archives, I found that he had a son names James Debrosses Jr. and he was married to Elizabeth Butler in 1762. There is also a record of James Debrosses buying a piece of land in New York in 1754.[6] Unfortunately this person has been lost in the pages of history over time.

Mordecai Gomez

Mordecai.im.jpg
Mordecai.im2.jpg

Mordecai Gomez must have been a prominent man during the early 1700s because I was able to find considerable information on him. To switch up the order, I began my journey into Gomez’s life at the Municipal Archive, and found a death certificate that recorded the birth of Mordecai Gomez in 1688 on the island of Jamaica, and his death on November 1, 1750 in New York. He was born to Luis Moses Gomez who was a very notable merchant of his time. My research continued back at the genelogy database on the first floor on the New York Public Library. Mordecai Gomez was married to Esther Rachel Campos of Jamaica, and had three children: Moses, Issac and Jacob. Unfortunately in 1736, Esther Gomez passed away at the young age of forty-one. Five year later, Gomez got remarried to Rebecca Haim de Lucena, through whom Gomez had four children: Moses Mordecai, Eve Esther also known as Hester, Rachel and Abraham.[7] The children from the first marriage were protected by the marriage contract dated April 23, 1741. Gomez married off his daughter, Eve Esther to Uriah Hendricks, which united two of the most prominent Jewish families together.

The role of Gomez during the trials was observed in the Horsemanden journal. Daniel Horsemanden records in his journals that since Mr. Mordecai Gomez was bilingual, he was the sworn interpreter at the trials, since some of the slaves required translation.[8] This made him a well-respected man in the community. During the second trip to the New York public Library, I found that after he became a freeman of New York on June 7, 1715, Mordecai Gomez was elected collector of the East Ward in 1723.[9] In 1733, a group of merchants petitioned for public control to insure higher quality of the flour that was intended for export, and Mordecai was one of them who initiated the petition. [10] Mordecai Gomez was a merchant and he did extensive trade in the Caribbean islands. He also owned two ships named Elizabeth and Hester, and they have been known to be involved in the slave trade.[11]

Mordecai Gomez was an active participant of the affairs of the Jewish community as well, and he initiated a petition for the “town’s permission to use two lots of land near the Apple Bush (Beekman’s Swamp) as a site or a new cemetery, since ‘the old one was full’ in August 1723.” As more Jews gained wealth, status and in number, and so they became more involved in the community. In 1728, of the 29 people who contributed to the cemetery and synagogue, 12 were Sephardic, and they gave more money than the remaining individuals. By 1747, tax rolls show that the two members with the largest assessment were Jacob Franks who was an Ashkenazi Jew and Mordecai Gomez who was Sephardic.[12] Mordecai Gomez’s political influence was well-known at the time. The colonial Assembly once met in Mordecai’s house in 1746, due to a fear of a smallpox epidemic in the original location. This is a conspicuous indication of the prominent position Gomez held in early New York. This elusive immigrant had left enough clues for anyone to spot him, thus become a prominent man in New York.

Below are some of the documents and articles that specify Mordecai Gomez's role in politics and in the community. It also includes a snippet from Horsemanden;s journal which describes him as the interpreter. It also includes the document that talks about Gomez's naturalization through the Act of 1741.

Gomez1741.png
Mordecai4.png
Mordecai5.png
Mordecai6.png


Mordecai7.png


Mordecai9.png


John Provost

Through my research at the New York Public Library, I was informed that the Provost family is one of the most prominent Dutch families and they have spread throughout the world. Through the genealogical database my research enabled me to come to the realization that among the common first names in the Provost family or Provoost family are John, James, and David. [13] This is so because of the Dutch tradition of naming children after their ancestors in order to honor and respect them. Therefore it is obviously difficult to deduce and find the one who I was looking for. But after comparing possible years of births and deaths, in relation to the slave conspiracy of 1741 as mentioned by Lepore, I concluded on one of the several thousand John Provost on the basis of the available information provided by Lepore. The Municipal Archive recorded that John Provost, also known as Johannes Provost was born on 28 Dec 1707 in Oyster Bay, Long Island, New York and died in 1781. Further I was able to come across the document that specified the marriage of John Provost to Elizabeth Youngs in Heampstead, Queens, New York on 23 May 1736.[14] They had two children, Samuel provost and Daniel provost. Through my research, I found that majority of the Provost family resided in New Jersey, and this is true up to today. John Provost obtained nearly 500 acres of land on Raritan Bay from the New Jersey Colonial Assembly.(Refer to map) To my surprise, after my trip to NYPL and finding out that Mr. Provost was born in Oyster Bay, LI, I was able to visit Oyster Bay along with my family the following week. Unfortunately I was not able to find any geneological center where I could have found any information on Mr. John Provost.

While going through the information available at the New York Public Library, I followed the Provost family: Following their marriage, John Provost and his wife went to Stamford and resided there, and probably lived on the land that Elizabeth inherited from her father John Youngs. Being a wealthy landlord, John Provost was one of the members of the jury during the Horsemanden trials who were against the slaves and provided evidence that led to the atrocities that were done to the slaves.[15] Based on my previous journey into the life of lawyer John Chambers, it could be concluded that John Provost is one such landlord to whom Chambers was giving a fair chance to be a part of the jury. Although I was able to conclude that like any other member of the Provost family, John Provost was also an heir to a significant amount of property and wealth, it was difficult to locate much information on him. “We can learn little of the subsequent history of John and Elizabeth Provost…” but this slaveowner has also been elusive to the world, and still only very minimal information is available on them.

Cornelius Van Horne

Cornelius van Horne was the son of Abraham van Horne and Maria Provost. Cornelius van Horne had a brother named Abraham van Horne.[16] Census Records that I observed reported that Cornelius lived in the Middletown Township in New jersey.(Refer to map)


My search for Cornelius always met dead ends. I realized that while going through city directories and other records, that Cornelius' brother Abraham van Horne was more prominent than him. There were several books and newspaper accounts of his brother, and very minimal wriiten about Cornelius van Horn. Cornelius was a politician in the Country party. One of the articles I came across pointed that in one of the elections, Cornelius van Horne lost to Adolph Phillips, and this led to many controversies, claiming that the votes were influenced by favoritism and an investigation was held.[17]

References

  1. Lepore, Jill. New York Burning. Page 206.Vintage Books, New York 2005
  2. The New York Genealogical and Biographical Record (quarterly-1931) – Extracts, New York Genealogical and Biographical Society 279
  3. Horsemandan, Daniel, The New York conspiracy, or, A history of the Negro plot : with the journal of the proceedings against the conspirators at New York New York 1810
  4. Copeland,David. Debating the Issues in Colonial Newspapers, The Zenger Trial: Partisanship, not freedom of expression, framed the case (New York: Publisher Unknown, 2000)
  5. New York City Wills 1771-1776 www.ancestry.com
  6. http://www.ancestry.com
  7. Markens, Issac. The Hebrews in America. New York: Behrman's Jewish Book House, 1975
  8. Horsemandan, Daniel, The New York conspiracy, or, A history of the Negro plot : with the journal of the proceedings against the conspirators at New York New York 1810
  9. Lebeson, Anita Libman. Jewish Pioneers in America: 1492-1848. New York: Behrman's Jewish Book House, 1938
  10. Calender of new York Colonial Commissions 1680 – 1770
  11. Hershkowitz, Leo. Original Inventories of Early New York Jews American Jewish History, Vol. 90, New York 2002
  12. Grinstein, Hyman Bogomolny, The rise of the Jewish community of New York 1654-1860 New York 1947
  13. http://www.provost.org/provost-genealogy.asp
  14. http://www.ancestry.com
  15. Horsemandan, Daniel, The New York conspiracy, or, A history of the Negro plot : with the journal of the proceedings against the conspirators at New York New York 1810
  16. http://www.ancestry.com
  17. New-York Gazette, or Weekly Post-Boy, published as New-York Gazette Revived in the Weekly Post-Boy; Date: 03-02-1752; Issue: 476; Page